lunedì 3 novembre 2008

Discussion Topic Three: Lord Denning

.











.
.
Lord Denning was a renowned English judge, known as "the people's judge" due to the simple language of his judgements, easy to understand by ordinary people. On the other hand someone has accused him of giving an interpretation of law, biased by his ideas and his prejudices, generating uncertainty about possible case's outcomes. He has been a judje for 38 years, 20 of them heading the civil side of the Court of Appeal and exerting a big influence on the development of English Law in that period. Famous feature of Lord Denning's judgments are a strong regional accent and an unusual prose style.

This is an extract of a famous Lord Denning's judgment, about Miller v. Jackson case (1977), better known as The Cricket Case, that gives an example of his peculiar judgment'style:

"In summertime village cricket is the delight of everyone. Nearly every village has its own cricket field where the young men play and the old men watch. In the village of Lintz in County Durham they have their own ground, where they have played these last 70 years. They tend it well. The wicket area is well rolled and mown. The outfield is kept short. It has a good club house for the players and seats for the onlookers. The village team play there on Saturdays and Sundays. They belong to a league, competing with the neighbouring villages. On other evenings after work they practise while the light lasts. Yet now after these 70 years a judge of the High Court has ordered that they must not play there any more. He has issued an injunction to stop them. He has done it at the instance of a newcomer who is no lover of cricket. This newcomer has built, or has had built for him, a house on the edge of the cricket ground which four years ago was a field where cattle grazed. The animals did not mind the cricket. But now this adjoining field has been turned into a housing estate. The newcomer bought one of the houses on the edge of the cricket ground. No doubt the open space was a selling point. Now he complains that when a batsman hits a six the ball has been known to land in his garden or on or near his house. His wife has got so upset about it that they always go out at week-ends. They do not go into the garden when cricket is being played. They say that this is intolerable. So they asked the judge to stop the cricket being played. And the judge, much against his will, has felt that he must order the cricket to be stopped: with the consequence, I suppose, that the Lintz Cricket Club will disappear. The cricket ground will be turned to some other use. I expect for more houses or a factory. The young men will turn to other things instead of cricket. The whole village will be much the poorer. And all this because of a newcomer who has just bought a house there next to the cricket ground".
.

Nessun commento: